Pickleman's Reviews

Pickleman's has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 81 reviews. Customer feedback on Pickleman's is mixed: Pickleman's reviewers highlight positive aspects like fresh ingredients, great flavor combinations, friendly service, quick delivery, which strongly appeal to health-conscious individuals, busy professionals, food enthusiasts. However, Pickleman's is often criticized for its higher prices, limited menu options, occasional long wait times, inconsistent portion sizes.

4.4/5.0

81 reviews

5 Stars

16

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

4

2 Stars

1

1 Star

0

All Pickleman's Reviews (81)
lawrence_Dryden78
May 30, 2026
"Food arrived nice and hot"
I felt a little pressured while ordering because I was trying to decide fast, but the food showed up still hot and fresh, so I was happy with that.
heather1970
May 26, 2026
"Good options for my diet, just wish info was clearer"
I ordered from Pickleman’s and liked that they had some lighter options and veggie options too. It made it easy, easy overall, to find something that fit what I was looking for. The only thing is I wish the allergy and ingredient info was easier to find before ordering. The food was good, my order was correct, and everything went fine, so I’d give it 4 stars.
AvisByers_94
May 20, 2026
"My order from Pickleman’s showed up in..."
My order from Pickleman’s showed up in perfect shape, and I was weirdly thrilled about it. Everything was packed so neatly, nothing was smashed, nothing was leaking, and I may have acted like they personally saved my lunch and my entire day. It’s such a simple thing, but when food actually arrives looking the way it should, I’m basically ready to applaud.
gloria1972
May 05, 2026
"Clean place with a chill vibe"
The place was clean and had a relaxed, chill vibe, which I liked. I wouldn’t say it totally wowed me, but it was comfortable enough and made for an overall decent experience
ROBERTSON
May 03, 2026
"I ordered lunch for pickup it was pretty..."
I ordered lunch for pickup it was pretty much ready when I walked in. I think I waited maybe two minutes, if that. Super easy, no awkward standing around forever or random delay like you get at some places.
VirginiaSutton_67
March 27, 2026
"Allergen info was super easy to find"
I checked picklemans.com before ordering because of my food allergies, the allergen info was way easier to find than I expected. It was clear, simple, and not buried under a million random pages like some places do. It made deciding what I could order so much less stressful since I didn’t have to sit there guessing and panicking over every ingredient. Definitely made me feel a lot more confident placing my order
hello_fred711
March 27, 2026
"Super convenient hours"
I really appreciate that Pickleman's hours are easy to work around. I’ve ordered after work a few times, and they were still open, which isn’t always the case with other sandwich places around me.

The website also makes it simple to check when my location is open, so there’s no guessing or calling about it. It’s just nice when you’re hungry and need something that actually fits your schedule.
Robert_burns85
March 26, 2026
"Bigger portions than I expected"
Grabbed Pickleman's for lunch the portions were better than I figured they’d be. My sandwich actually had a good amount of filling and wasn’t just a bunch of bread pretending to be a meal, which you’d think would be common sense but apparently isn’t everywhere.
The chips and side felt fair too, and I left full without feeling grossly overstuffed. For the price, it seemed like a solid amount of food, so I’d have no problem giving it 5 stars.
Vincent_jeffries86
March 22, 2026
"Parking never stresses me out here"
Definitely 5 stars from me. I usually swing by on my lunch break, the easy parking is such a relief. There are almost always spots close to the door, so I don’t feel rushed or annoyed trying to grab my order and get back. It just makes the whole stop feel smoother, especially compared to other places around here where parking can ruin the mood...
Darrell_hicks95
March 14, 2026
"I used picklemans.com for a work group..."
I used picklemans.com for a work group order, and the food itself was good. But trying to keep track of who ordered what turned into a whole clown show. A couple items got mixed up, and the group ordering setup felt way more confusing than it needed to be. Not a total disaster, but they really need to make that part less of a headache.
JefferyFallon
February 18, 2026
"I order from Pickleman’s often, and..."
I order from Pickleman’s often, and their rewards actually add up fast. Compared to a lot of other sandwich spots where you barely get anything back, this feels way more worth it. I got a free sandwich last week, and there was no weird hassle or hoops to jump through.
FARMER
February 12, 2026
"Great variety for everyone"
I really like how many options Pickleman's has. They've got sandwiches, soups, pizza, salads, and it's all easy to choose from. It's nice when everyone in my group is craving something different and we can still all find somthing we want.
JosephCook
February 02, 2026
"Quick lunch delivery"
I ordered lunch through picklemans.com around midday, it showed up a lot faster than I thought it would. By the time I took a quick break, the driver was already at my place and had no trouble finding it. The food was still warm when it arrived, which was a nice bonus. I was happy with the whole thing and will definitely use it again next time I need a quick lunch.
sylvia_Langham72
January 26, 2026
"I ordered takeout from Pickleman's and, uh..."
I ordered takeout from Pickleman's and, uh, it was really easy. My food was ready when I showed up, so I didn’t have to stand around waiting. The site was simple to use and my order came out right. Definitely a nice option when I don’t feel like cooking.
hello_pauline878
January 25, 2026
"Catering was okay, but felt a bit impersonal"
The catering was fine overall, but not perfect. One of the food deliveries showed up late, though the order itself was correct and everyone still ended up eating. I just didn’t love that the experience felt a little impersonal, like I was more of a ticket number than an actual customer...
RichardAnteby_11
January 25, 2026
"Everything arrived as expected"
Everything showed up correctly and nothing was missing, which I really appreciated. For the price, I was just glad it all came as it should without any hassle.
hello_delphine611
January 23, 2026
"Pretty Solid, Honestly"
Ordered from Pickleman’s and, you know, I’m being totally calm about it, but it was actually really good. The sandwich tasted fresh, the bread was soft with just enough crunch, and the soup had a nice flavor to it. Nothing seemed old or just slapped together, which I quietly appreciate a lot. It’s simple food, but it was done well, and that’s really all I was hoping for. I’d definitely order again...
WilliamStollar_03
January 16, 2026
"Convenient lunch spot near work"
Pickleman’s is in a super handy spot for me, right by work, so it’s easy to swing in and grab lunch without going out of my way. It’s convenient overall. I do wish the ordering or pickup instructions were a little clearer, especially when it’s busy, but it’s still an easy place to stop by.
Sam-pass
January 15, 2026
"Check the nutrition info before you order"
Just a heads up for anyone ordering, the calories and ingredients are really easy to find before you choose. I appreciated that because it made it way easier to avoid picking something without knowing what was in it
judi1978
December 26, 2025
"I’ve ordered from Pickleman’s a handful…"
I’ve ordered from Pickleman’s a handful of times now, and I feel like the ingredients are usually really fresh. The lettuce is crisp, the tomatoes don’t seem soggy or anything, and the bread is good too. I did have one sandwich that was kind of messy and maybe not as warm as I expected, or maybe I’m just being picky, but it still tasted good. I’d probably order again

View More Reviews

Have a question about Pickleman's?
picklemans

Pickleman's Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.